Showing posts with label science-fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science-fiction. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Orson Scott Card and Ender's Game

There’s been a fair bit of controversy on-line about Card, in the wake of the Ender’s Game film adaptation, focusing on Card’s “anti-gay” comments and his support of the anti-gay-marriage agenda. I guess one question in here is whether Card is really “anti-gay” because he opposes gay marriage. He has said on more than one occasion that he is not "homophobic" or "anti-gay," and that he has a number of gay friends. But he's strongly against gay marriage, and it seems to me that it really is hard to do the mental gymnastics that say that marriage should be reserved to heterosexual couples without in some way denigrating gays. If there isn’t something “wrong” with their relationship, if it isn’t in some way inferior, then why do we have to defend the “traditional” view of marriage (so-called, of course, since a more traditional view would be that marriage is between one man and multiple women, for instance).

I guess I’m going to dodge the issue a bit, by thinking about Card as an artist. Here’s the thing: I think Ender’s Game is a pretty brilliant book. And I think Speaker for the Dead is even better. This is some of his earliest work, and it’s great. There’s some other good stuff he’s written too, but more and more of his more recent stuff just seems flat by comparison. What I see in his earlier work is more of what Keats thought of as Negative Capability, which in fiction sows up as an ability to present vivid characters with relatively complex viewpoints interacting in what seems like a fairly natural way. More and more in his more recent work, Card seems to have axes to grind, points to score, and to my way of thinking that approach is far from brilliant. I suspect that it has a lot to do with his Mormonism. I don’t know if he was more “liberal” in his beliefs when he was younger, or if he was just a better writer, in the sense I’m thinking of it, but he really seemed more agnostic then, and his writing was better for it. Even if he wasn’t agnostic, I think maybe he was more in touch with people who believed differently than he did.

I remember in his forward to Speaker for the Dead, writing about the way that people have different relationships with and behave differently around different people and groups of people; he pointed to the way that as a college student (I think; maybe high school) he would do summer theater while living at home, and with his theater friends he swore like a sailor, while at home he was perfectly inoffensive in his speech. And I just wonder if in his younger days he wasn’t more in touch with a broader life, while as he’s aged he’s tended to be more around people who agree with him—or even who tacitly enforce certain norms on him—as well as living a more unified life. I can even identify, in a sense: as a youth, I was two people—one and home and one among my peers, but now that I’m an adult, I am more or less myself in all circumstances. Does that, perhaps, limit Card in certain ways?

I suspect the answer is yes. He still spins a pretty good story, but I haven't seen anything from him in quite a long time that I would call brilliant. And, returning to his stance on gay marriage, I suspect this, too, is a case of living in the echo chamber of his own religion and its implicit or explicit enforcement of moral norms. But I don't know Card personally and I recognize what a joke it is to think that I can psychoanalyze him from a distance and have any hope of being "right" about what moves him to say/write/do anything in particular. But part of being human, I think, is that we all have a right to our own opinions, no matter how tenuously based in actual knowledge they may be.

Oh, speaking of opinions and returning to the film: it was good for what it is--a film. It looked good, and it was close enough to the original, but it sorely lacks the depth of the novel (or of Ender's Shadow). It reinforces my belief that any book that's worth anything, if it's going to be translated to the screen it should probably become a television series. A Game of Thrones and its sequels, The Pillars of the Earth, World Without End: they've all been better than any film adaptation could have been (the exception just might be The Hobbit, which should have just been one film, not three; two, tops).

It did make me want to go back and re-read the book, which I suppose is a positive for the film.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Book Review: Embassytown

EmbassytownEmbassytown by China Miéville
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Embassytown is my second Mieville work (I found The City and The City interesting, enjoyable, and yet somewhat lacking). The novel seemed to spend a long time getting anywhere, and it was a bit hard to get into, the way that it got there, but in the end the payoff was worth it. This is probably more like 4.5 stars than 4--the slow build-up wasn't bad, per se, I just wish there could have been a more engaging way to pull us in deeper faster.

Our narrator, Avice Benner Cho, is a native of Embassytown, the human outpost on the alien world Arieka. She grew up there, got away from this fascinating backwater because she had the ability to immerse, to maintain consciousness while traveling through the Immer, which is the humans' method for faster-than-light travel across the universe. After she marries a linguist, however, she is drawn back to Embassytown by his desire to study the language of the Arieka Hosts, a desire to avoid the politics of her Immerser profession, and the subtle call of home.

The language of the Arieki is central to the novel. These aliens have a language that is unique in two ways: because they have two mouths, they speak a double language, a language which only makes sense with two voices; also, for them, language (or Language, since they can only conceive of one) is purely representative of reality, meaning--among other things--that they cannot lie. They also cannot learn other languages, or even really understand that other languages exist. Sometime in the past, through a fortuitous discovery, it was found that the only way humans could communicate with the Hosts was to have two speakers who were empathically linked in some way--from twins, they moved to clones, with special training to allow them to work as one. These doubled individuals are the Ambassadors, the only humans who can speak to the Hosts (or even be understood as speaking).

I don't want to get too far into the plot, but suffice it to say that intergalactic and local politics lead to a crisis of world-shattering proportions, which Avice and her allies must solve through a deeper understanding of these alien beings--as well as a greater understanding of human beings.

One of the sub-genres of science fiction is of the alien anthropology variety, hinging on the unique characteristics of an alien species that are understood dimly at best by the characters and the reader when the novel starts. It's a sort of puzzle or detective story, and in this case the aliens--however much their forms are strange to us--are ultimately at their strangest when it comes to the seemingly-simple difference of being incapable of lying, and the linguistic and consciousness differences that follow from that difference. In the process, Mieville offers an interesting exploration of what being human means, which in this case means beings who use language the way we do.

I listened to this novel as an audiobook, and I wanted to comment on the production as well. Susan Duerden, narrating, is Avice. The POV is 1st person narration, and she carries it off perfectly. I don't know how this was handled in the text version, but Language is represented here by two voices overlaid, as they are described to be, and it works nicely.

View all my reviews